Post #1: The Tragedy of Bonnie Bennett in "The Vampire Diaries"
For this first writing assignment, I plan to discuss the magical black best friend positive stereotype in relation to "The Vampire Diaries." For those unfamiliar with the series, Bonnie Bennett, one of, if not the, most important character in its 8-season entirety, is extraordinarily powerful, yet cast aside throughout, sidelined to her admittedly useless best friend, Elena Gilbert. As is true with many forms of media that coincide with this trope, Elena and the show's other white main characters aren't useless because they are white, but Bonnie is sidelined because she is black.

Bonnie is forced to help Elena and the Salvatore vampires, Elena's love interests, whether she wants to or not, and is made out to be selfish or villainous when she tries to refuse. Her storyline is exhausting and sad, considering how many times she is denied a chance at happiness, romance, or even a life of her own, continuously beaten down by the sometimes deliberate actions of the other characters. "The Vampire Diaries" is an excellent example of what makes this "positive" stereotype so terrible; though the black side characters, even apart from just Bonnie, are extremely powerful, magical, and beautiful, they are subject to torment by, and servitude to, the show's white main cast.
Hi Santana! First of all, I really like the layout of your blog. I'm excited to see how your paper evolves on this idea, it seems like it relates to the Stacy Whitman's Grimoire reading we did. Might be nice to reference that!
ReplyDeleteHello! I love your argument! I completely believe you when you say that Bonnie is "denied a chance at happiness, romance, or even a life of her own, continuously beaten down by the sometimes deliberate actions of the other characters," but since I haven't seen Vampire Diaries myself, for the next blog, could you add more examples of how this happens in the show? Also, I'm curious to know your opinion-- do you think that creators give black characters "power, magic, and beauty," in a way to excuse how they're still not fully fleshed out 3-dimensional characters? Love your blog, and am looking forward to the next one!
Delete-Nina Lu
Hi! This is a stereotype that deeply frustrates me so I'm very glad to see you taking it on! Although I have not seen this series, what stood out to me the most is that she is made out to be evil and villainous if she does not help Elena, which is something I see so often and is so manipulative. Looks good!
ReplyDeleteSantana, I love your viewpoint on this! I love The Vampire Diaries, and I completely agree. Bonnie is often left to be the strong one, yet she is usually overlooked and disregarded. Can't wait to read your paper!
ReplyDelete